The past week featured another round of qualifying games for the upcoming FIFA World Cup 2014 to be held in Brazil. Under the current rules, the six association football confederations (loosely representing the 6 continents inhabited by humans) each conduct a qualifying tournament to determine which teams will represent their confederation. The number of places in the World Cup Finals varies depending on confederation ranging from 14 places for UEFA (Europe) to 0 or 1 place for OFC (Oceania).
I got to thinking that perhaps it may be more fun and fair if for World Cup qualifying, the confederations were dispensed with entirely and qualifiers were played among national teams from around the world just as they play together in the finals. The confederations are oddly aligned as it is with Australia, a continent in its own right, has been a member of the Asian Football Confederation since 2006 so they could play more competitive matches. The South American nations of Guyana, Suriname, and French Guiana do not play in qualifiers with their South American neighbors in CONMEBOL but instead compete in the larger Confederation of North, Central American and Caribbean Association Football. So why not mix them all up and create a world-wide tournament.
My thoughts on the world-wide approach to World Cup qualifying is that it would provide several benefits:
- Dispense with the somewhat arbitrary number of places awarded to each confederation allowing places in the finals to be earned through qualifying competition.
- Allow nations with weaker teams to increase their level of competitiveness by matching up against some of the world’s best national teams.
- On the other hand, the higher ranking teams may use matches against minnows as an opportunity to test younger players under tournament conditions.
- Increase cultural exchange and international awareness among football players and supporters.
- Standardize the number of qualifying matches played. Currently, depending on the confederation, a national team may play as few as 8 matches and as many as 24 matches in qualification rounds, plus intercontinental playoffs for teams that did not qualify directly. My proposal would have each team that makes it to the finals playing in 12 or 18 games.
- Extend the drama and tension of the World Cup by having it build up over a two-year period of tournament play with the number of teams winnowed away until the 31 places for the finals are filled.
There are 209 member nations in FIFA. With the host nation automatically qualifying, that leaves as many as 208 national teams fighting for the remaining 31 spots. My proposal below works on the premise that all 208 national teams will be participating, although historically the greatest number of teams to enter qualification was 205 for the 2010 World Cup qualifying rounds.
Initially, I considered that the 208 teams could be drawn into 52 groups of four for the first round of qualification. Then I considered the possibility of high-ranking teams getting eliminated by other high-ranking teams early on while weaker sides advanced from less competitive groups. So for the round of qualification, some of the best teams in the world will have a bye as is already the common practice in the early round(s) of confederation-based qualification.
FIRST ROUND BYES
32 national teams will be granted a bye from participating in the first round. The byes may be awarded to the top 32 teams in the FIFA World Ranking at the time qualifying is to begin, or they may be given to the 32 teams that participated in the previous World Cup finals, or some other methodology agreed upon as fair by FIFA member nations.
Up to 176 teams may participate in the First Round of World Cup Qualifiers. They would be drawn into 44 groups of 4 teams each. Within the groups the teams play a double round robin (home and away against each opponent in the group) for a total of six games. The top two teams at the end of group play advance to the second round while the remaining teams are eliminated from qualification. To determine the order of teams in their group they will be ranked by points,then goal difference, and then total number of goals scored. If two or more teams are still equal on all three criteria then they will be ranked on head-to-head points, goal differential, and total goals. If teams remain tied and it affects what team may advance to the next round then a one-game playoff will be played at a neutral location.
The 88 teams that advance from the First Round and the 32 teams that received first round byes come together for a total of 120 national teams. These teams will be drawn into 30 groups of 4 teams each. In this round the top 30 teams will be seeded based on the current world rankings prior to the draw. Once again teams will play a total of 6 matches in a double round robin. The top two teams of each group advanced to the third and final qualifying round. The same ranking order and tie breakers described in the first round apply.
The 60 teams that survive the second round will once again be seeded into 15 groups of 4 with the top 15 teams seeded. Similar to the first two rounds, the teams play a double round robin within their groups for a total of 6 games. The top teams from each group advance to World Cup Finals. Third place teams may have one more chance in a playoff for the final spot. The same ranking order and tie breakers described in the first round apply.
PLAYOFF FOR THE 32nd SPOT
With 30 teams qualified joining the host nation, one last spot remains in the 32-team field. The 15 teams that finished third place in their groups will be ranked according to their performance in the second and third rounds combined (12 games total), with the top two teams (using the standard criteria for ranking and tiebreaker( advancing to a playoff for the 32nd place in the World Cup Finals. The playoff would be a simple two-legged home-and-away tie determined on aggregate goals with away goals, extra time, and then a penalty shootout used to break any draws.
And so we have our field of 32 teams winnowed down from 209. I’d think as each round progresses the tension and excitement would build leading into an exciting finals. What do you think? Would this be a fair and entertaining way of determining which national teams participate in the quadrennial event? Or would it be bogged down by unbalanced matches between top ranked sides and minnows? Would UEFA and CONMEBOL dominate the qualifiers and shut out the other confederations entirely or would we learn that the world is more competitively balanced than we ever imagined? Let me know your thoughts in the comments.