Author: J.K. Rowling
Title: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
Narrator: Jim Dale
Publication Info: Listening Library, 2003
The fifth book in the Harry Potter series is by far the longest novel, and one that may have benefited from judicious editing and abridging. I think this book has the most pages before Harry and his friends even arrive for their first day at Hogwarts! Having said that, I have to admit that actually enjoy the novel’s many tangents and subplots. I like reading Hagrid’s long tale of visiting the giants. And at the conclusion of the novel when Dumbledore finally explains what he’s been trying to do for 15 years, it’s a major information dump, but these are details I’m eager to suck up.
This novel may also capture Harry at his lowest ebb. Harry is angry and angsty for much of the novel, apropos to teenage behavior. But Harry has reason to be angry, having witnessed the murder of Cedric, suffered the insults of a Wizarding World that calls him a liar, and seemingly been abandoned by his mentor, Dumbledore.
The formation of Dumbledore’s Army is really a great moment in the development of many characters who have been supporting characters for much of the series but begin to come into their own. This novel also introduces one of my favorite characters, Luna Lovegood, which is amazing since she’s such a significant person in the series. But hey, I met some of my closest friends my senior year of college. I also like that Luna, Ginny, and Neville join Harry, Hermione, and Ron when they go to Ministry of Magic, again really expanding the story beyond just the core 3. The inclusion of Snape’s memory of being bullied by Harry’s father James and his friends is also a signficant addition to the backstory and how Harry understands his place in the Wizarding World.
The book does feature the major heartbreak of the death of Harry’s godfather, Sirius Black, a character I feel we never got to know well enough. I’m also curious why the Ministry of Magic keeps a giant arch that causes people who passes through it to die, because that was just a weird plot element, and something that really confused me about Sirius’ death when I first read this book.
So, yeah, this is a long book that doesn’t exactly flow narratively. But I enjoy wallowing in a few whirlpools along the way.